Diversity and Social Network Structure in Collective Decision Making: Evolutionary Perspectives with Agent-Based Simulations release_xl7olwsypzf5volj4dukqltvhq

by Shelley D. Dionne, Hiroki Sayama, Francis J. Yammarino

Released as a article .

2019  

Abstract

Collective, especially group-based, managerial decision making is crucial in organizations. Using an evolutionary theoretic approach to collective decision making, agent-based simulations were conducted to investigate how human collective decision making would be affected by the agents' diversity in problem understanding and/or behavior in discussion, as well as by their social network structure. Simulation results indicated that groups with consistent problem understanding tended to produce higher utility values of ideas and displayed better decision convergence, but only if there was no group-level bias in collective problem understanding. Simulation results also indicated the importance of balance between selection-oriented (i.e., exploitative) and variation-oriented (i.e., explorative) behaviors in discussion to achieve quality final decisions. Expanding the group size and introducing non-trivial social network structure generally improved the quality of ideas at the cost of decision convergence. Simulations with different social network topologies revealed collective decision making on small-world networks with high local clustering tended to achieve highest decision quality more often than on random or scale-free networks. Implications of this evolutionary theory and simulation approach for future managerial research on collective, group, and multi-level decision making are discussed.
In text/plain format

Archived Files and Locations

application/pdf  442.9 kB
file_wtjrxp5czvcgpctimdfr2nddo4
arxiv.org (repository)
web.archive.org (webarchive)
Read Archived PDF
Preserved and Accessible
Type  article
Stage   submitted
Date   2019-01-29
Version   v2
Language   en ?
arXiv  1311.3674v2
Work Entity
access all versions, variants, and formats of this works (eg, pre-prints)
Catalog Record
Revision: 3c6d9e16-9a7c-411a-9c94-f7eb8e4e2a3e
API URL: JSON