How good is our diagnostic intuition? Clinician prediction of bacteremia in critically ill children release_arpuf7smjzfbnkpi376fl3qoua

by Katherine Hoops, James C. Fackler, Anne King, Elizabeth Colantuoni, Aaron M. Milstone, Charlotte Woods-Hill

Published in BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making by Springer Science and Business Media LLC.

2020   Volume 20, Issue 1, p144

Abstract

Clinical intuition and nonanalytic reasoning play a major role in clinical hypothesis generation; however, clinicians' intuition about whether a critically ill child is bacteremic has not been explored. We endeavored to assess pediatric critical care clinicians' ability to predict bacteremia and to evaluate what affected the accuracy of those predictions. We conducted a retrospective review of clinicians' responses to a sepsis screening tool ("Early Sepsis Detection Tool" or "ESDT") over 6 months. The ESDT was completed during the initial evaluation of a possible sepsis episode. If a culture was ordered, they were asked to predict if the culture would be positive or negative. Culture results were compared to predictions for each episode as well as vital signs and laboratory data from the preceding 24 h. From January to July 2017, 266 ESDTs were completed. Of the 135 blood culture episodes, 15% of cultures were positive. Clinicians correctly predicted patients with bacteremia in 82% of cases, but the positive predictive value was just 28% as there was a tendency to overestimate the presence of bacteremia. The negative predictive value was 96%. The presence of bandemia, thrombocytopenia, and abnormal CRP were associated with increased likelihood of correct positive prediction. Clinicians are accurate in predicting critically ill children whose blood cultures, obtained for symptoms of sepsis, will be negative. Clinicians frequently overestimate the presence of bacteremia. The combination of evidence-based practice guidelines and bedside judgment should be leveraged to optimize diagnosis of bacteremia.
In text/plain format

Archived Files and Locations

application/pdf  470.6 kB
file_o32u2utwd5fwvhzehbf3bapcke
bmcmedinformdecismak.biomedcentral.com (publisher)
web.archive.org (webarchive)
Read Archived PDF
Preserved and Accessible
Type  article-journal
Stage   published
Date   2020-07-02
Language   en ?
Container Metadata
Open Access Publication
In DOAJ
In ISSN ROAD
In Keepers Registry
ISSN-L:  1472-6947
Work Entity
access all versions, variants, and formats of this works (eg, pre-prints)
Catalog Record
Revision: 08e15c44-c161-4346-aa58-cca56c21c47a
API URL: JSON